The Official Report is a written record of public meetings of the Parliament and committees.
All Official Reports of meetings in the Debating Chamber of the Scottish Parliament.
All Official Reports of public meetings of committees.
Displaying 1752 contributions
Finance and Public Administration Committee
Meeting date: 5 October 2021
Ross Greer
Good morning, cabinet secretary. I was keen to discuss with you the effect of the arbitrary cash-terms limits on the fiscal framework, but you covered that with Mr Mason. Therefore, I will move on to non-domestic rates, which you touched on in your answer to Liz Smith.
The total value of non-domestic rates relief through the various schemes that are on offer in Scotland comes to somewhere in the region of 拢700 million. That was expanded during the pandemic鈥攆or example, to the newspaper industry鈥攆or obvious reasons. I think that the decision was twice unanimously supported by Parliament. There is a range of options for non-domestic rates relief; what evaluation has the Government done of the effectiveness of the various schemes?
Finance and Public Administration Committee
Meeting date: 5 October 2021
Ross Greer
Thank you.
Finance and Public Administration Committee
Meeting date: 5 October 2021
Ross Greer
Excellent. That is appreciated.
You mentioned the regular requests that are made for additional rates relief. That is absolutely the case, but recently there have been more requests than I have noticed in previous years for additional conditions to be placed on rates relief. For example, in its evidence to the committee, the Scottish Trades Union Congress proposed conditions on fair work and the living wage, and Alcohol Focus Scotland has proposed that a public health condition be levied on licensed premises. Without necessarily commenting on any specific proposals鈥攜ou are, of course, welcome to do so, if you wish to鈥攚ill you comment on the principle of additional conditionality on rates relief, particularly given the challenging overall fiscal situation in the coming years?
Education, Children and Young People Committee
Meeting date: 29 September 2021
Ross Greer
I will explore that issue in a little more detail. Dr Stewart, you mentioned learning around co-production. What did you mean by that? Have you taken into account the concerns that have been raised about co-production and participation not just by the commissioner but by a range of other experts in the field of children鈥檚 rights?
Education, Children and Young People Committee
Meeting date: 29 September 2021
Ross Greer
I appreciate that, and I entirely understand that there is no easy answer to the question. However, given the comments of the children鈥檚 commissioner, I would expect you to engage with his office and with others to understand those concerns. I know that Dr Tracy Kirk has engaged with you on those issues.
Education, Children and Young People Committee
Meeting date: 29 September 2021
Ross Greer
I would like to explore the functioning of the NQ21 group, and specifically the level of participation of those involved. You will be aware that, on the day that the appeals process was confirmed, Cameron Garrett, who was the member of the Scottish Youth Parliament on the group, said:
鈥淎s the only young person who sits on鈥
the SQA鈥檚 NQ21 group
鈥渁nd the only member representing young people, I have not had an equal input into discussions around the appeals process this year at NQ group meetings.
Young people have been let down and ignored by this process.鈥
He went on to say that organisations such as the Children and Young People鈥檚 Commissioner and the people who are involved in the SQA: Where鈥檚 Our Say? campaign, as well as the Scottish Youth Parliament,
鈥渉ave been calling for a no-detriment policy and exceptional circumstances to be taken into consideration as substantive points. Neither have been considered in this process.鈥
Subsequent to those comments being made, did you reach out to Mr Garrett to better understand why he felt that way about his experience? Could you talk a bit about what you believe you have learned from those discussions and how subsequent processes to this one can more effectively involve the voices of young people?
Education, Children and Young People Committee
Meeting date: 29 September 2021
Ross Greer
Thank you. In a similar vein, the Children and Young People鈥檚 Commissioner Scotland made some pretty scathing comments about the concept of co-production. Dr Stewart said that that is an area of learning from the process over the past year. Bruce Adamson, the commissioner, made the same point that Cameron Garrett made. He said:
鈥淪ome very strange examples of 鈥榗o-production鈥 being discussed at the moment. If you have very limited involvement of young people and then ignore their views, you can鈥檛 call it co-production just because they were in the room.鈥
My question is similar to my question about Cameron. Have you met the commissioner subsequent to those comments being made to discuss his concerns about the concept of co-production?
Education, Children and Young People Committee
Meeting date: 29 September 2021
Ross Greer
I accept that.
I am conscious of the time, and I am probably intruding on the time of other members. If I could come back in at the end, that would be appreciated, but I understand if I cannot.
Education, Children and Young People Committee
Meeting date: 29 September 2021
Ross Greer
I am sorry to jump in. I do not particularly want to pursue the specifics of the appeals process, but, given that you have raised the issue and that we have had exchanges about it in the past, I note that there was not a particularly large number of appeals this year. Did any of those appeals result in a downgrade?
Finance and Public Administration Committee [Draft]
Meeting date: 28 September 2021
Ross Greer
What timescale has the Government given you for the work that will get you the more granular information that is required?